This year will be the 10th year (!!) that I've been doing this under my own MBA Apply shingle. Surprising that I never put together something like this, but consider this some best practices I've learned in the 10 years I've been working with tons of applicants from practically all walks of life.
1. GET THE GMAT OUT OF THE WAY FIRST BEFORE ANYTHING ELSE.
Preparing for the GMAT exam requires focus, and you owe it to yourself to get the strongest score you can. While a high score won't be an asset, a low score can keep you out. For top 16 schools, aim for a 700 at a bare minimum, and ideally a 720+. For top 30 schools, aim for a 660 minimum and ideally a 700+. It's not impossible to prep for the GMAT while working on your applications (and you may have to do both in parallel if you have to retake it), but the more time you have to prepare for the GMAT, the better. In essence, aim to finish your GMAT by May/June in the year in which you intend to apply (either for the October Round 1 deadlines or January Round 2 deadlines).
2. VISIT A FEW SCHOOLS WHILE CLASS IS IN SESSION.
Regular classes are held from September to April (with August being pre-term for some schools, and May being final exam month for most schools).
School visits can be invaluable. You get first hand experience with what a business school environment "feels like" in a way that no website, brochure, discussion forum, or second hand information can provide.
Aside from the Q&A info sessions that adcoms may organize as well as sitting in on class, perhaps the most invaluable insight you'll get about a specific b-school (or just b-schools as a whole) is to talk to current students one-on-one, where they will be far more likely to open up "off the record". Offer to buy them a quick coffee, beer or even a meal. They are broke (or heavily indebted) students who will appreciate free drinks and food.
Again, visiting schools isn't about currying favor with the adcoms at all (the only people they will remember are those who make complete asses of themselves because of the sheer number of people they come in contact with in any given year), but for your own sake. That first hand experience will make it easier for you to write about what you want from b-school in a more personal, specific way.
Aim to visit a few schools. They don't all have to be your target schools. For example, if you're heading to Chicago to visit Booth, go and visit Kellogg while you're at it even if you don't plan on applying there. Or, if you're heading to Philadelphia to visit Wharton, take a quick day trip to New York and visit Columbia and Stern.
Visiting 2-3 schools will not only de-mystify what b-school is like, but it'll only help you hone in on what it is you want to get out of the b-school experience.
3. APPLY TO 4-7 SCHOOLS TOTAL.
Since there are way more folks of a comparable caliber applying than there are spots available at any one b-school, the admissions process can be a total crapshoot. As such, it's a numbers game. Apply to too few schools, and you won't maximize your odds. Apply to too many schools, and you'll dilute your efforts across too many schools.
Target around 4-7 schools to maximize your chances, with the expectation that it's unlikely you'll get into every school you apply to. Spread it out across a range of schools: 2-3 stretches, 2-3 sweet spots, and 0-1 safeties. "Stretches" are schools where you have enough of a shot that they're worth applying to, but you'll need a bit of luck to get in. Sweet spots are schools where you have a more reasonable shot of getting into given your profile. Safeties are schools where you are virtually guaranteed to get into.
4. AIM FOR A SWEET SPOT OF 5-10 WEEKS TO COMPLETE ALL YOUR APPLICATIONS.
Although completing the applications does take some time, effort and focus - there isn't so much to do that it is a full-time job. Give yourself at least 5 weeks, and at most 10 weeks to complete all your applications, with the expectation that you'll be working on it a few hours each week.
Anything less than 5 weeks, and chances are you'll be rushing to get them in before the deadlines. Anything more than 10 weeks, and you risk "overworking" and overthinking your essays (polishing them to a point where your second-guessing will actually worsen the quality of your written applications). There is only so much you can do before it ends up being an exercise in rearranging the furniture.
This means if you're applying for Round 1 deadlines, as long as you begin by mid- to late-August, you should be fine. And for Round 2 January deadlines, you should start on your essays no later than mid- to late-November.
5. FOCUS ON ONE SCHOOL AT A TIME.
Around 80-90% of your time and effort will be spent on the first 2-3 applications (or even the first 1-2 applications, depending on the degree of overlap in the essays for your target schools).
You will find that once you've completed a few schools, each additional school will take very little time. In fact, by the time you get to your 4th school and beyond, it can take a week or even just a day or two to get them done.
Even if the essays or messaging are different from one school to the next, there's a learning curve - once you're "in the zone" after having done a few and you have a more natural feel for writing b-school essays, you'll find that it progressively takes less time to complete each subsequent application.
Focusing on one school at a time will help you focus, while also giving you the best chance of completing your entire list of schools in the most effective manner.
You don't have to be dogmatic about completing them one at a time, but avoid working on them in parallel as much as you can. What this also does is it gives you time away from a particular application, and that time away is invaluable, because it allows you to revisit the applications with a fresh set of eyes before you submit. What you may find is that while working on your 5th school application for example, you discover some new insights that you can incorporate into your 1st school application - insights that you may not have come up with had you tried to juggle a bunch of school applications at once and feeling overwhelmed about it.
6. THINK, WRITE AND SPEAK IN PLAIN ENGLISH.
For many b-school applicants, they have forgotten how to write in plain English, because most if not all of the writing they have been doing since college has been in a corporate work environment.
Every industry has their own shorthand, jargon, and figures of speech - to the point where in some cases it has morphed into its own dialect that only people in that industry can understand.
Most applicants can write about their personal lives or anything they do outside of work in plain English (no one would ever say "My spouse and I consolidated into a mutually beneficial union due to our aligned interests"). However, a lot of applicants have never had to write, speak or even think in plain English at work, because everything at work is communicated in an industry dialect or "corporate speak." Just bear in mind that if you are talking about your work in a resume, essay, or interview - you will likely have to act as your own English translator.
One effective way to help you write in a clear way is to read your essays out loud. If it sounds stiff, abstract and formal - then it probably is. Your essays should sound like YOU outside of work. The language should sound like how you talk, except without the decorative "ums, ahs, you know's, see what I mean, like, yeahs, " and so forth.
7. HAVE OTHERS READ AND CRITIQUE YOUR ESSAYS.
Feedback is essential. That third person perspective is something you do not have when you're knee deep in your essays.
Get your friends, colleagues, family members, or even paid consultants to review your writing for clarity, specificity, economy and tone.
Chances are, you will get conflicting feedback. That's normal. Narrative writing is subjective, and not everyone will have the same opinion about your "story" - what you wrote, or how you wrote it. As the author of your narrative, it is a judgment call (and yours alone) as to what feedback to incorporate and what to ignore. Frankly, the entire application process is a judgment call from both the applicant's and adcom's perspective. However, you can make more informed choices about your essays (in whole or in part) when you get feedback from others who are not in your head.
8. GIVE YOUR RECOMMENDERS 4-6 WEEKS TOTAL TO COMPLETE ALL THEIR REC LETTERS - NO MORE, AND NO LESS.
This may sound counter-intuitive, but you do not want to give your recommenders too much time. The reason is simple: the more time you give someone, the more time they have to procrastinate. And the more they procrastinate, the more likely they'll rush to submit it at the very last minute. Don't project your own stakes onto others: yes, the applications mean a lot to you personally, so you'll be more motivated and uptight about every single little thing, trying to get everything done and to the tee. Your recommenders frankly don't have those stakes, even if they really like you, and as is human nature - they will procrastinate and sit on it if given the chance. You would too if you were in their shoes and being asked to write them for someone else.
Having said that, by all means, talk to potential candidates who you would like to write your recommendation letter a few months before the deadlines so that you can finalize who your recommenders will be.
But give them the materials to submit their recommendation letters around 4-6 weeks from the deadline. That way, they have enough time to write them to the best of their ability, but not so much time that they can completely set it aside and forget about it.
9. AIM TO SUBMIT IN THE 1ST OR 2ND ROUND; AVOID THE FINAL ROUND
For most schools, they build most of their class from their first two rounds, so by the time the last round comes around, there are few spots left and as such, the decision process is even more subjective and random. This is especially the case if you are a traditional applicant (finance, consulting, engineering, healthcare, corporate) because it's unlikely they will need or want any more traditional applicants by the time they review applications from the final round. If anything, they are hoping to fill the class with more non-traditionals from non-profit, military, arts/entertainment/sports, and so forth. Again, nothing is impossible, but if you can, avoid the final round.
If you are undecided between the 1st and 2nd round, just know that it makes no difference from an admissions perspective (your chances are the same). However, I have found that applicants who aim for the 1st round tend to be more productive, even if they are busier at work. The reason for this is simple: when you are busy at work, you have no time to navel gaze or to procrastinate. You just execute.
The 2nd round tends to be a more difficult deadline to aim for simply because of the holiday season: from Thanksgiving to the New Year, it's a dead zone. A lot of applicants mistakenly believe that because they have all the time in the world because they will be with their families or on holiday, they can focus on their application. And they are often wrong, because it's much harder to substitute between "personal time with family/friends" and "b-school applications". It's far easier to procrastinate and waste time when you have that time to waste, and there's this mad rush to complete the application nursing a New Year's hangover.
So ideally, aim for the 1st round, but know that the 2nd round is also fine (except that it'll likely be more difficult for you in terms of time management). And avoid the last round if you can.
The only exception to this is Columbia and Sloan - the only schools that have 2 rounds of admission. For both of these schools, treat their 2nd round as the "final round." In other words, for Columbia and Sloan, aim for their Early Decision and R1 deadlines respectively.
10. TREAT THE ENTIRE APPLICATION PROCESS AS PARALLEL TO YOUR CURRENT CAREER TRACK.
In short, don't quit your job to focus on the GMAT or the b-school application. It doesn't signal to the adcom that you're focused. Instead, it tells them that you're not as competent as the other applicants out there who can still put together strong applications even as they are juggling work, family and extracurriculars.
If you happen to be unemployed at the time of application, make sure you're staying productive on something, whether it's volunteering, working freelance gigs, or just something that is allowing you to continue moving your life in a forward direction. The last thing anyone wants to see is someone who is in a holding pattern in their life, as if b-school is some panacea they are waiting for before giving themselves permission to make life choices.
And this goes for those who are also currently employed. Treat the b-school application process as a parallel track. If you get in, it should be an *option* (the option being: "should I go, or should I stay in my current job, or even should I switch to another job?"). It should not be the only door you're waiting for to open.
B-schools want to accept people who don't need them, just like a bank tends to lend money to those who need it the least. B-schools appreciate enthusiasm, but there can be a fine line between enthusiasm and desperation, and there is no worse turn off than a desperate person.
The more you treat b-school as an option (and not a necessity), the more likely it'll come across in how you communicate in your essays as well as in your interviews. You're more likely to come across as confident and enthusiastic, as opposed to desperate and needy.
Showing posts with label GMAT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GMAT. Show all posts
Tuesday, March 18, 2014
Monday, April 22, 2013
IS BUSINESS SCHOOL WORTH IT?
IS BUSINESS SCHOOL WORTH IT?
One of the most basic but important question I get from
folks is whether an MBA is worth it (and in particular, a full-time program).
The debate seems to have been going on ad infinitum, with
sentiment ebbing and flowing with the state of the economy.
From a practical standpoint for many folks who are deciding
on whether to apply or not (or whether to attend or not * after * they have
gotten admission!), the answer may be clearer than you’d expect.
1) CONSULTING: AN MBA IS BASICALLY A PREREQUISITE
Regardless of your prior professional background, if you’re
looking to work as a management consultant at firms like McKinsey, Bain, BCG,
Monitor, LEK, Accenture, Deloitte, etc. then an MBA is worth it, because you
don’t really have much choice: you’re highly unlikely to get hired without one.
Even if you are a consultant looking to upgrade your brand
(i.e. you work at a small no-name consulting firm and hoping to work at
McKinsey), your chances are slim unless you get an MBA. And even if you are
looking to stay at your current firm, you will likely be highly encouraged to
go back to do an MBA (read: your chances of getting promoted to a post-MBA
position are slim unless you have one).
Moreover, for many of these firms, you essentially have to
shoot for the top 16 US programs (and LBS and INSEAD in Europe), since these
consulting hire the majority of their incoming associates from these programs. You
will get some MBA hires who did not go to these schools, but they are a
minority. They will also hire some folks from law schools or direct industry
hires, but for the most part, consulting firms have a highly structured (and
highly stratified) recruiting process that focuses on a select number of
schools.
2) FINANCIAL SERVICES: AN MBA IS A MUST IF YOU DON’T HAVE A
FINANCE BACKGROUND
Regardless of what aspect of financial services you’re
looking to work in – investment banking, equity research, sales/trading, asset
management, private equity, hedge funds, venture capital, commercial
lending/underwriting, insurance, etc. – if you don’t have a finance background
and looking to make a career switch into it (even if you have
corporate/business experience), then you’ll have a very hard time getting these
jobs without an MBA.
The culture of financial services doesn’t value the MBA to
the same degree as consulting, but it is often seen as a passport to getting in
the door for those with no prior relevant experience. And areas such as
investment banking focus their recruiting efforts almost exclusively on top 16
MBA programs.
Also, if you’re in a “back office” or “middle office” role
at a financial institution (or you’re in any support function such as IT at a
bank), and you’re looking to make that switch into revenue generating functions
as listed above, then an MBA is worth it to re-brand yourself because it’s hard
to make that switch without one.
While some schools have introduced specialized Masters’
programs in finance, these programs are still relatively new compared to the
established MBA programs. Basically, if you had the choice, the MBA is the
better bet and will give you more access to recruiters than a specialized
masters program.
3) NON-BUSINESS PROFESSIONALS SEEKING A CORPORATE CAREER IN
THE US
If you are coming from a non-business profession (engineer,
science researcher, lawyer, doctor, military officer, teacher, athlete, artist,
etc) and looking to transition into business job function, then an MBA can be
extremely valuable. Although not a must like it is for consulting or financial
services, getting an MBA is certainly worthwhile enough since making that
transition into a business career will be easier and faster.
“Corporate life” basically includes the two industries above
(consulting and financial services), but also any job function on the business
side in any industry: marketing, operations, financial planning/corporate
finance, business development, corporate development, human resources, investor
relations, etc. In many of these jobs beyond the college entry level, they
require either relevant prior experience or an MBA (and most of these firms
will not hire you to start alongside fresh college grads at the entry level).
4) BUSINESS PROFESSIONALS SEEKING TO SWITCH INDUSTRIES
Basically, an MBA makes it much easier if you’re looking for
a fresh start (without having to fully start over) in a new industry. For
example, you’re a brand manager at a consumer products company who is looking
to switch into business development at a green technology firm. Or, you’re an
investment banker looking to work in sports marketing.
This also applies to social enterprise and non-profit, since
the kinds of jobs you would be aiming for on the admin/managerial side tend to
be staffed by “corporate refugees” who previously worked in the private sector,
and tend to hire people in their own image (i.e. those with business
backgrounds and/or with MBAs).
Of course, it’s certainly more possible to make this switch
without an MBA (unlike the other three situations above), but an MBA will make
it a lot easier for you to make that switch without having to take a huge step
back in pay and responsibility.
--------
So if any of these four things applies to you, then the
answer is easy: an MBA is worth it (assuming you believe these careers to be
worth pursuing), even without considering any of the intangibles or personal
factors, such as the network, taking two years off for personal “me” time,
discovering new interests, learning more about other careers, and so forth.
SO WHEN IS THE MBA NOT WORTH IT FROM A CAREER STANDPOINT?
Simply put, an MBA won’t have much benefit from a career
standpoint if you are already working in a business job function AND you’re not
interested in switching to consulting or financial services.
For example, if you’re a banker or PE guy who wants to stay
in finance (in any capacity), an MBA won’t be worth it from a career
standpoint, because an MBA isn’t going to make it any easier for you to change
from one firm to the next, or from a PE to a HF and back again. It ultimately
comes down to your transaction experience, network, and the job market in the
industry - when it’s hot, you will have firms coming to you; when it’s cold, an
MBA won’t help you land jobs that don’t exist.
Or if you’re simply looking to move up the ladder in your
industry in a similar job function, then you don’t need to go back full-time:
consider doing a part-time MBA or an executive MBA down the road.
Finally, if you’re looking to start your own business in the
short-term, you are better off investing that money in wise counsel and getting
that business off the ground right away while the idea is still hot in your
mind, rather than spending two years in business school where you will learn
mostly “book knowledge.” The biggest problem with business schools and
entrepreneurship is that business schools unwittingly teach students to
conceptualize their way through problems as a substitute for rolling up their
sleeves and getting their hands dirty. In plain English, they confuse analysis
for execution, and running your own small business often lives and dies more on
the latter than the former.
THE MYTH OF THE LONG-TERM
Forget about the long-term value or even the medium-term
value of an MBA. The reason why is simple: it’s debatable, it’s a matter of
opinion, and it’s ambiguous. You will get more conflicting and differing
opinions on this than you would on what it will do for you in the immediate
term (i.e. right after graduation). Furthermore, if the value of the MBA in the
short-term is limited at best in your situation, then it’s not going to be any
more valuable in the medium- or long-term.
When deciding whether an MBA is worth it to you or not,
focus on the short-term benefit: what it will do for you in terms of recruiting
while you’re an MBA student? Will it give you access to the kinds of jobs you
want immediately after graduation? While it may seem cynical to disregard the
academics – the reality is, the MBA is a professional degree whose main purpose
is to turn students into employable business professionals after graduation, so
the academics aren’t an end in itself, but a means to that end. While business
schools would like to say that they want to teach you knowledge that you can
use for your entire career long-term, the reality is, the kind of knowledge and
decision-making you do in the long-term will have little to do with what you
learned ten years prior in b-school, and more to do with your recent
experiences and lessons learned in the past three to five years. Again, the value of what you learn in business
school is most relevant (if not exclusively relevant) to your first few years
after business school.
In plain English, the MBA is ultimately about helping you
secure the kinds of jobs in the short-term you want that you couldn’t have
gotten without the degree (or would at least make it a lot easier for you to
secure those kinds of jobs). That, more than anything else, dictates whether
the MBA will be worthwhile to you.
WHY BUSINESS SCHOOL ADMISSION IS LIKE GETTING SIX-PACK ABS
WHY BUSINESS SCHOOL ADMISSION IS LIKE GETTING SIX-PACK ABS
As an admissions consultant, what I do in a nutshell is to coach people on their applications – the essays, resume, recommendation letters, application forms, interviews, and just about any issue under the sun that pertains to business school: career goals, business school life, and whether even to bother applying to school at all.
As an admissions consultant, what I do in a nutshell is to coach people on their applications – the essays, resume, recommendation letters, application forms, interviews, and just about any issue under the sun that pertains to business school: career goals, business school life, and whether even to bother applying to school at all.
In many
respects, what I do for business school applicants is analogous to what a
personal trainer does for fitness clients.
One of the
most common queries I get from prospective clients is this:
“I have a
GMAT that is much lower than the averages for my target schools. Can you help
me overcome that?”
The quick
answer is, no. Is there a chance you can get in DESPITE a lower GMAT?
Absolutely. But that doesn’t involve “essay magic.” It’s luck and highly
unusual circumstances (you’re sleeping with the adcom, you have the President
of the United States backing you, your parents have a building in the school
named after them, and so forth).
Believing
that somehow a low GMAT can be easily mitigated by an exceptionally executed
application assumes that there are enough of your fellow applicants who will
have crappy applications. The thing is, regardless of GMAT score, just about
all applicants will be putting in their best effort. A lot of applicants with
GMAT scores that are average or above average are going to be putting in great
applications. Gone are the days where the majority of applicants were submitting
in crappy essays. With all the resources and knowledge out there that are just
a few Google searches away, most applicants have the savvy and know how to put
together specific, clear, organized and polished essays. And yes, quite a
number of these folks who have average to above average GMATs are also getting
help – from consultants, MBA alums, colleagues, and other people who are giving
them feedback on their applications.
So any
consultant who claims that they can somehow pull the wool over an adcom’s eyes
and get them to admit you in spite of a low GMAT is akin to those TV
infomercials selling abdominal machines with the promise of six-pack abs.
To claim
that using their abdominal exercise contraptions can give you six-pack abs
isn’t outright lying, but it’s misrepresentation. Yes, you can get six-pack abs
with exercise (crunches, sit ups and any form or combination of abdominal
exercises). But all the exercise in the world won’t give you those six-pack abs
if your diet and genetics aren’t already putting you in a position to make
those exercises effective.
And that’s
what the GMAT is – it’s like diet and genetics. All the “essay magic” in the
world won’t really help to fundamentally change your chances if your GMAT is
out of range.
So this may
seem like I am working against my own interests – I mean, as an admissions
consultant, I should be telling you that “hey, if you sign with me, I can help
you overcome your GMAT score!”
But that
would again be akin to a personal trainer telling you that your diet and genes
are not important – so long as you follow his/her patented “transcendental metaphysical
crunch!” method, you will get ripped in just 45 days or less. Would you trust
someone who is more focused on sales than on giving you honest advice that
serves your best interest? In other words, are you looking for a sales person,
or an advisor? There’s that old saying that if it sounds too good to be true,
then it probably is (or they are giving you a sales pitch).
In other
words, I can certainly help make sure you’re doing the best you can on the
applications so as to maximize your chances – but you’ll still be a stretch if
your GMAT isn’t competitive, plain and simple.
I know that
the GMAT is a pain in the ass. I hated it myself. I have a greater aversion to
sitting still figuring out multiple choice questions than the average person. But
it’s one of those necessary evils. And if you have tried all you can, taken it
multiple times and still cannot hit the ranges of your target schools, then
it’s something you have to simply man up and live with. This doesn’t mean you
should just give up and not apply at all – but that if you do apply with a
significantly lower than average GMAT score, just have some realistic
expectations of where you stand. That may be hard to hear, but it is the truth.
Before
embarking on the actual applications, you need to do whatever it takes to score
within range for the schools you’re targeting.
The irony
is, those who care least about the GMAT are those who probably need to boost
their score, and those who obsess over their GMAT probably need to relax and
focus on the applications.
In short,
here’s the rule of thumb:
You need to
be within 20 points of your target school’s incoming GMAT average, and ideally
at the average or more. That’s it. A much higher than average score will not
help, but a score that is 20 points or more below the average will be a
significant handicap.
In sum, the
GMAT isn’t the ONLY factor for admission, but it is an important first hurdle.
In other words, having an average GMAT is just the starting point to determine
whether you are even in the running or not for your target b-schools – much
like a great diet and genes are necessary before even determining whether
exercise can even get you the six-pack abs you want. ###
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)